Benedictine spirituality? Perhaps this term is more ambiguous than it
seems. Does it mean Saint Benedict's spirituality? Or the spirituality of
the black monks as distinct from the spirituality of the monks of Citeaux,
Calmoldoli and all the other branches which stem from Benedictine roots?
Does it mean the different forms that Benedictine spirituality has taken
throughout the centuries? Or does it mean Benedictine spirituality as it is
practiced today? Some historical facts will best reveal the differences and
at the same time will highlight the constant factors of a religious thought
that is eminently and basically one because it has its origin in traditions
that are truly authentic and because it seeks always to renew itself by
returning to its sources.
Information about his life is scant. The only document that contains a few
facts is the second book of the "Dialogues" of Pope Saint Gregory (590-
604). This brief biography, despite the many marvels recorded in its pages,
gives us a fairly clear outline of the saint's spiritual life and enables
us to see his place in monastic tradition. But the strictly historical
content of the book is slight.
While still very young he began the study of literature. Realizing that his
virtue was in danger, he fled from Rome "wisely ignorant, prudently
untaught" and hid in a lonely cave not far from the present city of
Subiaco. At the end of three years his retreat was well-known and disciples
came to him from far and near. The pettiness of a priest neighbor who was
jealous of his reputation for sanctity forced him to move to Monte Cassino.
There he founded a monastery where he remained for the rest of his life.
It is almost impossible to free ourselves from a romantic picture of Saint
Benedict, standing before us like some great medieval abbot, crozier in
hand; we see him as a dignified ecclesiastic teaching his doctrine with the
majesty of a pontiff. He made his community into a family, looking always
to the splendor of divine worship, professing a broad and all-embracing
humanism, opening a new era in the history of western monasticism: an era
which would place monasticism at the service of the Church and enable it to
play a prominent part in the development of European art and thought.
A recent authority, Dom Cuthbert Butler, the Abbot of Downside, who died in
1934, has told us that Benedict was a respectful but firm opponent of the
ascetic traditions which came from the deserts of Egypt and Syria. Against
a too-individualistic spirituality which tended to excessive corporal
mortification and which insisted on the primacy of the eremitical life,
Saint Benedict rose to vindicate the rights of an asceticism which was more
humane and, to speak frankly, more Christian.
No texts support these opinions. First of all, there is nothing in Saint
Gregory's account that allows us to conclude that Saint Benedict
deliberately rejected solitary life because he had discovered the higher
value of common life. It was the invasion of disciples eager to be molded
by him which forced him to leave his solitude and organize the community
which was forming around him. Moreover his Rule formally repeats the
traditional teaching that the eremitical way of life is the path of the
Like Saint Anthony and all the great doctors of eastern monasticism, Saint
Benedict is primarily an ascetic and charismatic. He lacks none of the
gifts that mark the man of God: power of intercession which rarely failed,
authority over demons, ability to read hearts, discernment of spirits,
knowledge of the future, bilocation. His prayer was uninterrupted and was
usually accompanied by the gift of tears. His contemplation seemed to
culminate in an extraordinary vision in which the whole world was
concentrated, as it were, in a single ray of the sun.
These gifts were given to Benedict at the close of a rigorous "ascesis"
which carried him to perfect "apatheia" in which all his carnal passions
were totally and forever at peace. Then men, in search of the perfect life,
chose him to be their father and doctor, he never deviated in the smallest
way from an insistent solicitude for the soul's moral development. The
anecdote about the jar of oil is typical:
"At such time as there was a great dearth in Campania, the man of God had
given away all the wealth of the Abbey to poor people, so that in the
cellar there was nothing left but a little oil in a glass. A certain sub-
deacon called Agapitus came unto him, instantly craving that he would
bestow a little oil upon him. Our Lord's servant, who was resolved to give
away all upon earth, that he might find all in heaven, commanded that oil
to be given him: but the monk that kept the cellar heard what the father
commanded, yet did he not perform it: who inquiring not long after whether
he had given that which he willed, the monk told him that he hat not,
adding that if he had given it away, that there was not any left for the
Convent. Then in anger he commanded others to take that glass with the oil,
and to throw it out of the window, to the end that nothing might remain in
the Abbey contrary to obedience. The monks did so, and threw it out of a
window, under which there was an huge downfall, full of rough and craggy
stones upon which the glass did light, but yet continued for all that so
sound as though it had never been thrown out at all, for neither the glass
was broken nor any of the oil shed. Then the man of God did command it to
be taken up again, and, whole as it was, to be given unto him that desired
it, and in the presence of the other brethren he reprehended the
disobedient monk, both for his infidelity, and also for his proud mind."
This is the spirit that characterizes the Rule. It is a manual of
asceticism; it is also a code that regulates the daily life of the
monastery according to the spiritual progress of those who live within its
walls. Monasticism continues to be what it has always been: an attempt to
live the whole Gospel, far from the world, awaiting the City of which God
is the architect and builder.
It is true that Saint Benedict tempers the ascetic rules of the East with
gentleness and moderation.
We have, therefore, to establish a school of the Lord's service, in the
institution of which we hope to order nothing that is harsh or rigorous
(Prologue of the Rule).
To the sick he allows meat, and those who think they need wine may have it
(chapters 36, 39, 40). The Abbot, he tells us, ought to order and arrange
all things so that souls will find salvation and brethren will do what they
have to do without any just ground for complaint (chapter 41), or as he
says in another place, the Abbot must act so that the valiant will have
something to strive for and the weak will not be tempted to be discouraged
(chapter 64). Rightly, it would seem, does Saint Gregory praise the
"discretion" of the Rule, the care that is taken to avoid any excess, to
make adjustments for different conditions and to impose no burdens too
heavy for the imperfect to bear. It is this moderation that shows us that
Saint Benedict truly understood the concrete possibilities of human nature
and desired to win souls by gentleness rather than to act on them by
Does he, in this way, depart from the old monastic spirit? Only the most
superficial could think so. Cassian devoted the second of his Conferences
to "discretion", or "discernment". Saint Anthony--the first Egyptian
hermit of whose history we are certain (d. 355)--preached that this was the
most necessary of virtues. It is true that the documents on occasion relate
some forms of abstinence that are slightly out of the ordinary: for example
Macarius of Alexandria filled a narrow-necked jar with little pieces of
bread and then allowed himself only as much food as his hand could grasp
once each day.
To feats like this the eastern monks never attached any absolute value and
they frequently pointed out the root error of judgment or of vanity which
destroyed their spiritual utility. One day Abbot John, the superior of a
large monastery, paid a visit to the hermit Pesius and asked him how he had
spent the forty years of his solitude.
"Never", replied Pesius, "has the sun seen me eat."
With a smile his guest added: "And it has never seen me angry."
Alluding to, but not insisting on, corporal mortification, Saint Benedict
seems to find the whole of asceticism in obedience, which is to him the
highest form of renouncement, since it has for object man's self will. But
for this, too, he is indebted to Pacomius and Cassian. Pacomius subjected
his monks to a rigorous discipline: to read his Rule is to receive the
impression that no one in his monastery could so much as lift a little
finger without his superior's permission. Cassian considered the
renunciation of one's own will to be the chief reason for common life and
he said that without it there could be no control of one's passions, or of
monastic stability, or of brotherly peace.
Far from opposing any personal formula of his own to the traditions of the
east, Saint Benedict allows us to see that he felt a certain nostalgia for
"For those monks show themselves too slothful in the divine service who say
in the course of a week less than the entire Psalter, with the usual
canticles; since we read that our holy fathers resolutely performed this
task in the space of a single day (chapter 18).
Although we read that wine is by no means a drink for monks, yet, since in
our days they cannot be persuaded of this, let us at least agree not to
drink to satiety (chapter 40).
If however, the needs of the place or poverty require them to labor
themselves in gathering in the harvest, let them not grieve at that; for
then are they truly monks when they live by the labor of their hands, as
our fathers and the apostles did (chapter 48).
But for those who hasten to the perfection of the monastic life, there are
the teachings of the holy fathers, the observance of which brings a man to
the height of perfection... Moreover, the "Conferences of the Fathers,"
their "Institutes" and their "Lives" and the Rule of our holy Father Basil-
-what else are they but examples for well-living and obedient monks and
instruments of virtue? But to us who are slothful and ill-living and
negligent, they bring the blush of shame (chapter 73)."
From the great traditions of eastern monasticism Saint Benedict borrows
most of his observances: community of goods (chapter 33), poverty of
clothing (chapter 55), exact obedience (chapter 5), silence in the Abbot's
presence (chapters 6 and 7), the division of the community into deaneries
(decanii) or groups of ten monks presided over by a dean (decanus; chapter
21), the number of the psalms in the night office (chapter 9), the three
occupations at stated times in the day: prayer, sacred reading and manual
labor (chapter 48), the brevity of silent prayer in choir (chapter 20),
perpetual abstinence from meat (chapters 36 and 39), broad and generous
hospitality (chapter 53), a retreat far from the world and all its noise
(chapters 4, 66, 67).
Like the fathers of monasticism he shows a certain mistrust for the
priesthood, considering it to be a trap for humility (chapter 6z), and far
from seeking to attract recruits, he rebuffs candidates who volunteer of
their own accord (chapter 58).
But the most fundamental of all the characteristics that link him with the
east is the idea he forms of monastic life and its special purpose. To him
it has no other goal than to enable its adepts to live with gospel logic,
to follow Christ to the end. No secondary goal is to be proposed lest the
disciple, concentrating on it, run the risk of deviating from what is
Saint Gregory has written that Saint Benedict, in entering his solitude,
had no other desire than "to please God alone", "soli Deo placere
desiderans." These simple words, better than any others, explain the
monastic vocation. This springs from a desire to please God, or to seek
God, as the Rule puts it (chapter 58). This desire is so strong, so
penetrating, that it exercises an exclusive empire over the soul and
permits no other deep or dividing preoccupation. Cassian's abbot asked only
one question of his candidate: "Does he truly seek God? Is he zealous for
the 'opus Dei,' for obedience, for humiliations?" (chapter 58).
No other criterion is considered because this one alone is valid in
discerning vocations. To become a monk means that life's sole purpose is to
go to God by the path of detachment, to overcome self-will, to embrace
freely-accepted humiliations, to devote one's self to the "opus Dei" which
is easily the most disinterested of religious actions and the one most
centered in God. It means to have no apparent care for human learning, no
ambition to play a role in society, no immediate apostolic aims.
Work has meaning only because of its ascetic value and temporal necessity.
Guests are welcomed with respectful charity but no effort is made to
attract them to the monastery. Young boys and adolescents are educated, but
only to train them for religious life.
The life of Saint Benedict and of his monks, such as it is described in the
"Dialogues," gives us no other picture of monasticism. In the eremitical
period, when the saint lived unknown by men, the isolation of the cenobites
of Subiaco and Cassino was neither absolute, nor systematic. Contacts with
the people of the neighborhood seem to have been relatively frequent.
Shortly after his arrival at Cassino, Benedict tried by continual preaching
to win for Christ the people of the region who were still pagan and he
looked after the virgins who were consecrated to God. But all this was
merely the result of circumstances: it never went beyond the ordinary
obligations of charity. The definition of a monastery is "a school for the
service of the Lord": its only purpose is to form perfect Christians.
Dom Herwegen wrote of Saint Benedict that "his great work was to teach, to
live and to express in his rule as a Roman and a westerner the monastic
tradition of the east." Care must indeed be taken not to make the founder
of Cassino an eastern monk who has wandered to the west. Saint Benedict is
in every sense Latin. But--and this is what I have been at pains to prove--
he respects the traditions of the east which are to monasticism what
apostolic tradition is to faith in the Church. And to eastern tradition
Benedict intends to be faithful. To forget this dependence is to
THE FORMATION OF BENEDICTINISM
The Benedictine Rule does not seem to have been written only for the
monastery of Cassino. A number of points may be noted that indicate a
desire to adapt it to different places and circumstances. Whatever be the
explanation of this still unexplained fact, there can be no doubt that
Saint Benedict's work did not win instant and universal acceptance. When it
began to be widely known--and this was not until a century after the
author's death--it was still only one ascetical text among many others. In
fact, everywhere it met an old and well-established monasticism which seems
to have taken forms far different from the original inspiration.
From the middle of the fourth century, if not much earlier, the east had
known an urban monasticism in which the monk's flight from the world was
necessarily relative. Nevertheless so many of its customs were like those
of the east that its members can be considered true monks. The same cannot
be said of communities who were connected with city or country churches.
Their members took care of divine worship or devoted themselves to
different works of mercy in the Roman deaneries. Dom Pierre Salmon has
pointed out that these groups were monastic only in appearance: "Without
vows or true rule of life or preconceived plan these devout laymen and
clerics came together to live a more intense Christian life. Contemporary
documents show us, in the vicinity of the basilicas, buildings which were
called "monasterium," "basilicae monasterium," "domus basilicae." They
housed "clerici canonici" who lived according to the "priorum canonum
regulam," as well as the "monachi," "custodes," "servientes," "fratres,"
"matricularii," "pauperes." Over these people was an "abbas," a secular
superior and head of the basilica. Together they took care of the services
in the basilica of which the celebration of office was an important
These clerics and devout layfolk led a community life which made them
resemble monks. Yet they lacked the monks' absolute detachment,
renunciation of personal independence, separation from the world and
In time these communities of canons began to influence the true monasteries
and an exchange of vocabulary became inevitable. Dom Olivier Rousseau
The somewhat vague and undefined monastic vocabulary is fundamentally in
keeping with the Latin character which willingly takes pleasure in
hierarchic groupings, in worship, in offices centered about a sanctuary and
in an altogether liturgical form of pious life. Benedictine monasticism
could not have escaped their influence.
This vocabulary took shape in a clear and definite way beginning in the
eleventh century with canons regular: this was to be the point of departure
for the different branches of the Order. But during the six preceding
centuries this formula tended unconsciously to blend with the rule of Saint
Benedict, and by that very fact was one of the important elements of
Benedictine life. Just as the rule of Saint Columbanus more or less will be
combined in many places with the Benedictine rule, in the measure that the
latter will spread; so the "canonical" germ, if we may use the term, will
be combined with the rule in the development of most monasteries, taking
root, whether men are willing or not, through a secret connaturality of the
Latin spirit in the old monastic pattern brought from the east and making
considerable modifications in it... The more or less extensive introduction
of the priesthood into monasticism, the well-regulated recitation and chant
of office in common, the daily attendance at chapter and conventual mass,
the liturgical and later the pontifical pomp of the abbeys are all products
of this double tradition.
Through these modifications of the Rule, the chief elements of the old
monastic life were soon combined with some of the customs adopted by the
canons in their communal religious life. The wonder is that these elements
have come down to our day, and have infused their spirit into a body where
external form would have seemed to the fathers of the desert, as they still
seem today to easterners, far from compatible with the primitive ideal. The
man most responsible for this fusion is Saint Benedict of Anianus who died
in 821. He persuaded Charlemagne and Louis the Pious to require all the
monasteries in the empire to follow the Benedictine Rule. In this way he
gave monasticism in all its forms the leaven which was to renew its early
spirit and forestall a swift decadence which seemed inevitable.
The reforms of Saint Benedict of Anianus were continued, expanded and
brilliantly transformed by a little abbey founded in 910 by Duke William of
Aquitaine on his lands in Burgundy. Next to Saint Benedict and his Rule,
Cluny is the greatest event in the history of western monasticism. The
honor given it by popes and emperors, the part played by its abbots in the
politics of their day, the limitless riches of its charity, the grandiose
proportions of its churches, the splendor of its services, above all the
intensity of its reform, all these tend to hide from us the simple reality:
Cluny introduced a marvelously disciplined monastic life which was
scrupulously faithful to what it considered the spirit of the Rule, if not
to the Rule's very letter.
It must be admitted that for our present purpose the strictly Cluniac
documents are usually rather disappointing. The abbots of the great years--
Odo, Mayeul, Odilo and Hugh-- wrote rarely on subjects that were
specifically monastic. Their biographies are models of conventional style
and give us only the most commonplace facts. To grasp the Cluniac spirit we
must question Peter the Venerable, the ninth abbot who died in 1156. Dom
Jean Leclerc has given us a well documented life of this Benedictine. He
describes his hero's idea of religious life in these words:
Because it means the renunciation of legitimate dignities and of all that
is great on earth and even in the Church, because it is "a hidden life",
the monastic state is the most lowly in Christian society, the least
exalted in the hierarchy, so that Peter the Venerable can often find no
other word to describe it except humility. Before this word denotes the
monk's private virtue, it indicates the place the monk occupies in the
Church where he never seeks to shine. Just as we speak of "the pontiff's
majesty", so ought we to speak of "the monk's humility".
If Alger and two other canons of Liege began to be true monks when they
entered Cluny, it is because they ceased to be masters and became humble
disciples. Monks must have no other ambition than to be "humble and calm";
the greater the service they can render to monasticism, the more they ought
to preach humility by word and example. Cluny is built at the lower end of
a valley. This site is a symbol of the life led there. Men humble
themselves in the monastery for the sake of Christ, they humble themselves
here on earth so as to be raised with the blessed in heaven to God. Peter
the Venerable's insistence on this point shows that he was convinced that
the monastic state had no hierarchical rank. It was in this, he believed,
that it differed from the clerical state, the state of prelates, canons,
priests, masters, whatever be the name given to ecclesiastics who officiate
in the Church. The monk agrees not to play any visible role and this
humility is an authentic form of spiritual poverty. The monk gives up the
possibility of prominence in the world for the same reason that he refuses
to possess anything, because man can glory in the goods he owns as well as
in the good he does, he can be complacent about what he has and about what
he is. To be willing to have nothing, to do nothing great, to be detached
from all things is the surest way of dying to self (pp. 92-93).
Monastic life at Cluny was therefore essentially contemplative. It was
directed towards what Peter the Venerable in his fidelity to the vocabulary
of Cassian and the whole mystical tradition used to call "heavenly theory"
and had no other goal than to prepare all, and to lead some, with more or
less frequency and more or less intensity, to the actual practice of this
Never could Peter the Venerable have said of all of his monks, what he
could say of some among them as, for example, of Brother Benedict:
"Striving night and day, with all his strength, towards divine theory, his
spirit transcended things mortal and with the blessed angels he was
absorbed in an uninterrupted inner vision of his Creator."
But, it was true, that all Benedictine life was lived in an atmosphere
which Peter describes in words which are synonymous with leisure, rest,
silence. He has not left us a systematic treatise of the reality hidden in
these words. Instead he uses them so frequently and so simply that we can
discover the meaning he ascribed to them. Rest is a state that becomes a
religious. To reform a monastery is to restore its rest. The leisure of the
blessed in heaven is "leisure without labor", while religious life is
"leisure with labor": the first is "exoccupatorum otium," the second is
"negotiosum otium." Now the Gospel explains how we are to understand
monastic leisure. It is the labor of Mary sitting at the Master's feet,
listening to His words, never leaving His presence. Mary's leisure is the
opposite of Martha's work. This leisure, which in no way resembles lazy
idleness, consists in the performance of purely spiritual acts: the monk
prays, reads, sings psalms and fulfills his other religious duties. Life
lived according to this program, is divided between reading and meditating
seated in the cloister, or reciting the divine office in choir with the
brethren, or praying alone prostrate before the altars of the church (pp.
Peter the Venerable sums up in a few words what he considers the role of
monasticism in Christianity to be:
"The monks, to a large extent, watch over the salvation of the faithful,
although they administer none of the holy sacraments. They confide all the
Christian people living on their lands to priests and clerics."
Peter the Venerable compares the work done by secular priests baptisms,
confessions, sermons, with the work done in the cloister: prayers, psalms,
tears, alms,--in these good works the monks are specialists. It was with
these means that Cluny remade Christianity (p. 114).
Similar ideas are found in a little work of John, a man of God who died
about 1049. His book has been called "Liber de vitae ordine et morum
institutione." This first Abbot of Fruttuaria was a disciple of Saint
William of Dijon; he may with good reason be considered typical of the
Cluniac school. According to him, a monk had to flee from Egypt to reach
the desert and climb Sinai (chapter IX, 27). He embraced a state of
mourning and of tranquillity, of modesty and meekness (chapter II 11)
Silence is a virtue peculiarly his own (chapter IV, 12). His goal is purity
of heart and plenitude of virtue (chapter XI, 34).
In Jean de Fecamp (d. 1078) and Pierre de Celle (d. 1183) the mystical
"elan" is more marked. The former pours out the ardor that consumes him in
"confessions" which are very personal in character: they are lyrical
meditations on the great dogmas, and flowing aspirations to intimate union
with God. The latter selects themes from sacred Scripture which are not
much more than pretexts for his thoughts about contemplation and the
contemplative life. Life in the cloister is for him a preview of heaven. He
sees it only from this angle. The monk's characteristic occupations are
those that most closely resemble the essential activity of life in heaven:
the vision of God.
Was the day of a Cluniac monk so filled with psalmody that little time
remained for reading and study? Those who say yes, base their answer on a
text of Saint Peter Damian which is not free from hyperbole. The
quotations we have just cited indicate the contrary. It is remarkable that
the Cistercians never reproached Cluny with these prayers of
supererogation. No allusion to this is found here, nor in the works of
Saint Bernard, nor in the other Cistercian documents listed by Dom
Wilmart. Moreover, Cardinal Matthew of Albano, legate of the Holy See and
former prior of Saint Martin-in-the-Fields, held it against the Abbots of
Cluny of the Rheims province that they were influenced by Citeaux and
suppressed these additions to the office which, according to him, were
meant to fill the spaces made in the day by abandoning manual labor. Men
who lived then did not seem to see that all this vocal prayer was an
obstacle to contemplation. The considerable place given in Cluniac
monasticism to liturgy and its extension is not an isolated phenomenon. It
reflects the spirit of the time and with justice it could not be condemned
THE EREMITICAL MOVEMENT IN THE 11TH AND 12TH CENTURIES
Paralleling the movement that started in Cluny, less daring reforms sprang
up and flourished in other parts or France and Europe. It is difficult to
discover the mutual influence that links them together. As far as
essentials are concerned, the spirit everywhere is the same: it was a
question of the re-establishment of discipline by a more exact observance,
if not of the rule itself, at least of the secular traditions of
An eremitical tendency has been discovered in some of these movements. Of
this there had been no signs in the preceding period. A well-informed
historian, Dom Germain Morin, has gone so far as to speak of "a cenobitical
crisis in the eleventh and twelfth centuries."
Through the influence of Cassian and also perhaps because Byzantine
monasticism then flourished in southern Italy, the lives and teaching of
the desert fathers began to be at this time a force independent of Saint
Benedict and traditions peculiar to the west. Thus Chartreuse came into
being in 1084 and has always denied any connection with Benedictine
monasticism. In the same way, about 975, the Benedictine monk Saint Romuald
felt drawn toward solitude and became without any willed effort on his part
a reformer of monasteries. He was, as one of his disciples said, "the
father of reasonable hermits". To these men he gave a rule and new fervor.
We look in vain to Saint Romuald or to Saint Peter Damian (d. 1072), his
disciple and his biographer, for the spirit of discretion which was
characteristic of Saint Benedict. We find instead in them the superhuman
ardor of men inspired. Romuald's many journeys, which carried him wherever
the Spirit moved him, do not remind us of the peace and stability preached
by the father of the monks of the west. Romuald's rigorous asceticism won
for him the veneration of the people, but it was beyond the strength of the
average man. As for the writings of Peter Damian, they have none of the
gentleness of the Rule: they contain violent diatribes, pitiless
excoriations of the vice of these days. In them are to be found
exaggeration of language and much seeking after effect.
This somewhat frenetic exaltation does not lead to peace, which is the
fruit of solitude, or to "spiritual leisure", "spirituale otium." Saint
Romuald condemns monks and abbots for their neglect of rule, their love of
luxury, their spirit of independence, their failures against silence; he
makes no effort to take them from their life of recollection and prayer. On
the contrary, he preaches silence. He would like to oblige abbots to adopt
it because he sees that it is the normal state of the spiritual man who has
reached perfection and is called by that very fact to strengthen others
with the abundance of his contemplation. He does not soften the monastic
ideal, he merely traces a profile with straight lines, made taut as it were
because of effort: a symbol of an age when passions were violent and minds
tended to go to extremes.
CITEAUX: THE RETURN TO THE RULE AND THE SCHOOL OF CHARITY
Until recently, the foundation of Citeaux (1098) was represented by
historians as one attempted reform among many others, as an effort to
restore observance which had been undermined by relaxation, weakened by
tepidity. Father Othon Ducourneau has corrected this legend. In the
beginning Citeaux was not opposed to Cluny as a house of strict observance
to a relaxed monastery. The founders were inspired to do more than merely
strengthen discipline: beyond the legitimate customs made sacred by the
practice of seculars, they wished to return to an observance of the whole
Rule and the Rule alone, without addition or subtraction. This explains the
suppression of food and clothing not authorized by Saint Benedict, the
return to perpetual abstinence from meat, the renunciation of every kind of
revenue which was not the direct result of work, as well as the decision to
eliminate from the office all superfluous prayers and ceremonies. The
objective was not austerity for its own sake but the re-establishment of
the purity and simplicity of the Rule.
To this careful search for the truth and this return to the sources,
corresponds a precise doctrine of the spirituality of love. Contrary to
what its literal interpretations might lead us to expect, from the very
beginning Citeaux is a school of charity.
"Twelfth-century France was filled with schools of profane science and
ancient letters. There was not only Saint-Vorles, where the young Bernard
pursued his studies, with a program that might well astonish, not to say
disquiet, a soul so eager for Christ --there were Paris, Reims, Laon,
Chartres, so many other famous names but always the same masters: Cicero,
Vergil, Ovid, Horace, eloquent spokesmen of a world that had never read the
Gospel. Why not invoke another master, the only master who has the words of
eternal life?.. Citeaux, Clairvaux, and Signy were then to stand over
against Reims, Laon, Paris and Chartres, schools against schools, and to
vindicate in a Christian land the rights of a teaching more Christian than
a guileless youth were wont to be poisoned."
While the Cistercian order was expanding rapidly, there was at the same
time an admirable flowering of doctrine based on the soul's knowledge of
self, and on charity, or the knowledge of God. The spiritual development of
the first Cistercian century reached its perfection in Saint Bernard, who
died in 1153. He was the perfect example of the cloistered soul illumined
by the practice of love, of prayer, of "lectio divina," of asceticism, In
him, "monastic theology," the daughter of "patristic theology", found its
most perfect representative in the very hour when it ceased to be.
FOREIGN INFLUENCES,. MODERN DEVOTIONS
The twelfth century witnessed a remarkable growth of monastic spiritual
life as well as the dawn of scholasticism. Dialectics rather than the study
of mysteries is about to triumph. Theology is to become more and more
speculative, its structure more and more systematic. Wisdom gives place to
knowledge. By way of contrast, another form of religious thought takes
shape; later it will be called "spirituality" and find expression in what
will be known as "devotional literature". The study and classification of
the soul's movements, methods of prayer, the direct cultivation of
religious sentiments and introspection win a place for themselves apart
from the contemplation of mysteries. Theology has now become pure
intellectual activity, and at the same time "spirituality" stresses what is
affective, individualistic, and moral, and it concentrates on what concerns
man rather than God. Just as theology loses its living contact with the
Bible, so spirituality turns back, as it were, upon itself: the word of God
no longer yields substantial nourishment.
Monks were not to escape this evolution. The division of Christian thought
carried them along strange paths which were no longer a part of their own
traditions. There is nothing specifically monastic in the writings of a
John of Kastl (died after 1410), or a Louis Barbo (died in 1443), or a
Garcia of Cisneros (died in 1510), or a Louis of Blois (died in 1566). They
belonged to one or another of the schools of spirituality then in favor.
Judged in this light, they have real value, but they cannot be considered
to be the faithful depositaries of old traditions.
On one point, however, they do not deviate from this tradition: all,
without a single exception, consider monastic religion to be purely
contemplative, and when they are concerned about their brother's spiritual
needs their efforts are directed towards intensifying his taste for
interior life. When they make use of a strictly methodical spirituality, it
is not because they are speaking to, or believe they are speaking to,
apostles in the midst of active life, it is because methods of this kind
are just as necessary for men whose hearts no longer seek strength from the
living sources of Scripture and the Fathers. Although they did not know how
to rediscover the unity of theology and life, of knowledge and experience,
they did have this merit-- among many others-- of championing the primacy
of love and the attraction for Gospel values against the claims of a dry
and fruitless scholasticism.
TWO PARALLEL MOVEMENTS IN THE MODERN PERIOD: REFORMS AND CLERICALIZATION
Beginning in the twelfth century there was a marked decline in monasticism.
Here we need not tell the story of the many and varied causes of this
decline. In fact, if not by right, monasteries became more and more
secular. "The abbey became a fief, and the abbacy a benefice." The abbot is
now a lord and a prelate. He rules but he no longer guides his monks by
word and example. Very often, he is placed in office by those outside the
monastery, and he is chosen for reason of politics or family. Often he is
not even a religious but a secular and he is called a commendatory abbot.
Now we know that, "As are superiors, so are their subjects". In their turn
monastic offices become benefices which are the object of covetousness
within the monastery, and competition without. Places in a monastery are
strictly limited and they become a kind of prebend, the object of men's
ambition like membership in a secular chapter. Vocations do not flower
under the inspiration of grace. Recruitment is vitiated at its source.
Noble families reserve vacant places in a monastery so that their sons will
find there a career.
Many abbeys now accept only candidates from the nobility. As a result the
community's inner life gravitates about the interests of one family or
another. Under such conditions, can regular discipline be maintained?
Monasticism's high position in the feudal world was in itself a danger.
When monasticism became a very active factor in that system, it became
materialistic, it lost something of the supernatural character of its
origins and destiny, it was in part laicized. Withdrawn in the beginning
from the world, this path brought it back to the world. Its duties became
secular and, once weakened, they were eventually absorbed. From the middle
of the twelfth century this great body began to experience a dangerous
Other causes combined to threaten a regular religious life. Abbeys were
impoverished by a depression and a currency depreciation. So great was the
consequent poverty that in many places, the question of finance took
precedence over all others. So complicated had become the administration of
the goods of the monastery that, as a result of the fluctuation of money
and changes in the cultivation of the soil, the monks had to spend all
their day working their land. Divine office was neglected, studies
"General Chapters" were held to remedy these evils. They were first called
through the private initiative of individual abbots who were impressed by
the success of the system in the Order of Citeaux. Later they were the
object of general laws of the Latin Church. Connected with these attempted
reforms are the names of Innocent III (1198-1216), Honorius III (1216-
1227), Gregory IX (1227-1241) and Benedict XII (1332-1342).
"Congregations"were formed as a result of the General Chapters. These
congregations were stable unions of monasteries wishing to return to a more
regular observance and to defend themselves against the interference of
laymen. So we see that prior to the Council of Trent the congregation of
Saint Justin of Padua was formed in Italy, that of Bursfeld in Germany,
that of Valladolid in Spain, that of Chezal-Benoit in France.
The Council made membership in these groups obligatory and congregations
began to multiply. The most famous were the congregation of Saint-Vanne
which was established in 1604, and that of Saint-Maur which was established
in 1621. The will to reform was especially evident at Saint-Maur where a
centralized government was adopted which resembled in some ways the pattern
followed by orders founded after the twelfth century.
The influence of these newer orders was also evident in the work of the
external ministry. The ordination of monks to the priesthood became the
general rule. Often parishes near abbeys which had once been confided to
secular priests now were served by members of the community, at least in
Germany, Austria and Switzerland. Nevertheless the monks never seem to have
been as active in the apostolate as were the new orders; yet it is hard to
see how they differed from canons regular: they had schools, they preached,
they heard confessions. Some abbots were consecrated bishops and they
administered the land of which their abbey was a part. In 1776 Louis XVI
entrusted five military schools to the Maurists. From "this commerce and
engagement in the world," Dom Mabillon would defend studies against the
attacks of Rance.
From our point of view it must be noted that there was a real desire to
return to the sources. Saint Benedict's Rule was read, meditated,
commented. Reference was made to it constantly. Its spirituality remained
basically unchanged. The Maurists, for example, whom we always remember for
their learning, were also prolific ascetical writers. Their spiritual
treatises show that they knew much about the Fathers but that they failed
to grasp their whole spirit. Their interior life had no roots in the
theology of the Fathers, nor in the word of God.
The difficulty about studies--to which I have just alluded-- was felt
keenly and became involved only because there was no agreement as to the
exact boundaries of the domain of knowledge and of "devotion". Men in those
days seem to have failed to see that the two may be happily combined,
provided that the former (by this I mean theology) is true to its nature.
Reflexive spirituality enjoyed new triumphs. How could it be otherwise?
"These old houses of religious women needed a reformation, and the
Benedictine monks, who were only just beginning to reform themselves, were
not yet numerous enough to undertake the reformation of their Sisters
single-handed; it was therefore imperative that the reform should be
brought about in a more modern spirit and by younger hands. In vain did
Oratorians, Capuchins and Jesuits try to steep themselves in the Rule of S.
Benedict, in the renovation of which they worked hard; they remained to the
core modern men, post-Tridentine religious. Consequently our Abbeys,
without losing the essential features of their primitive originality,
received a new impress. The Order of S. Benedict had meditated long before
the Council of Trent or the birth of S. Ignatius. It seems, however, that
this reform within the reform, if the phrase be allowed, introduced into
the Abbeys an interior life more systematic and orderly, and more
resembling that of newer congregations, in a word, more conformed to the
Ignatian "Exercises." The reformers were not content to return to the
regularity of old days, enclosure, poverty, liturgical splendor; they
endeavored, besides all this, to mold the Benedictines by methods and
practices unknown to the first centuries of the Order."
Would the results have been different had the monks reformed their sisters?
Probably not. Benedictine spiritual writings of this period closely
resemble similar works written by members of other religious orders. Dom
Claude Martin took the trouble to dictate the exact sentiments his novices
must make their own at every hour of the day. Dom du Sault considered the
divine office to be but one "exercise" among many others. To fit it in
between meditation and confession, seemed to him as good a place as any
other. The same author devotes many pages to the subject of meditation, and
then gives only two pages to reading.
The days of the Maurists were also the days of the Trappists. Rance
hurled his anathemas against the relaxation of his black-robed brothers and
stigmatized their zeal for studies with the voice of a prophet. In spite of
obvious exaggerations and prejudices his great work, "De la saintete' et
des devoirs de la vie monastique" (1683), sounds a note that is clearly
traditional. It does, however, reveal an attraction for an asceticism that
is artificial and forced, and to tell the whole truth, somewhat theatrical.
Whatever be the value of these too easily formulated criticisms, it must be
acknowledged that a deeply religious Benedictine spirituality developed
during these centuries and we must admire and respect its dignity, fervent
conviction and austerity. The lovable charm of a Louis of Blois, the
moderation and humility of a Mabillon, the stout good sense of a Dom Calmet
remind us of Saint Benedict. Contact with thoughts far different from his
own did not make his sons lose any of their desires to conform themselves
to his spirit.
To Dom Prosper Gueranger (1805-1875) we owe the restoration of Benedictine
life in France after the great Revolution. The first abbot of Solesmes
began his work with no knowledge of monastic life beyond what he had found
in books. Despite a thousand difficulties, he chose by instinct all that
belonged to the period of the high middle ages rather than to the days of
Saint Vanne and Saint Maur. It must be confessed that his principles and
his thoughts are not free from romanticism: he was a man of his times. But
they contained a seed that has not ceased to flower and bear fruit: a love
for Christian antiquity, a deep understanding of the liturgy, a desire for
perfect purity in the pursuit of the monastic ideal. Dom Gueranger greatly
influenced the black monks. This influence is still felt today. Thanks to
him they are recognized as the champions of the modern liturgical movement.
Because of him, consciously or unconsciously, directly or indirectly, they
have been forced to weigh their own vocation, to recognize its inalienable
greatness. In different ways and from different points of view the works of
Dom Maur Wolter, of Dom Delatte, of Dom Marmion, of Dom Butler, of
Dom Herwegen, of Dom Stolz, of Dom Vandenbroucke, of Father Bouyer
(of the Oratory), of Dom Steidle --only to name the most important
writers-- reveal this interest in Benedictine sources and a deepening study
of Saint Benedict's program.
Advances in historical studies, a keen desire for sincerity, simplicity and
truth, the needs of an age that avidly seeks to escape from all the
inhumanity of a troubled civilization-- all these bring the monks back to
their beginnings and fill them with a longing to be exactly what they are.
Because of its simplicity it is difficult to grasp this ideal and find
terms that will adequately convey its meaning to our minds. Yet this is
what we must now attempt lest we merely repeat under another form the
fruits of our historical survey.
A reader may have received the impression that I have carelessly combined
two different points of view: monastic spirituality and monastic life. The
answer is easy: here life and spirituality are one. According to the
probable etymology of his name, "monos" means one and so it may be said
that the monk is a man with one thought that unifies all his acts in the
pursuit of one end. God alone! This is the motto of every true Christian,
of every sincerely religious man and the monk takes it literally and
applies it with a rigor and logic that is at times disconcerting.
Basic in every monastic vocation is the desire--a desire whose object is
sometimes obscure and uncertain--to leave, to flee, to escape from the
world and creatures. The words the angel whispered to Saint Arsenius:
"Flee, be silent!" are addressed to all whom God has chosen to serve Him
alone. The monk has a sharpened perception of the caducity of all that
belongs to this world, of the vanity of all that the eye can see. Earth is
a place of exile: here man's stay has a beginning and an end. Moreover the
earth itself will pass away. Beauty of nature and of art, masterpieces of
human industry all will perish in the general conflagration. Then new
heavens and a new earth will appear--the dwelling place of justice. Why
then accord so much thought to the purely transitory? Saint Peter Damian
advised: "Let us leave secular things to seculars. Servants of God ought to
be as dead to a world doomed to death."
The monk does not condemn in any way those whose role it is to build up the
earthly city, but he knows that is not his vocation. Even at the risk of
being misunderstood he flees to the desert or hides in his cloister. To his
own age he makes himself a stranger so that here and now he can become a
citizen of heaven. This is his philosophy, his vision of the world: in the
eyes of men it is foolishness, in the eyes of God it is wisdom.
This is not merely negative. Dom Gueranger was able to say that "separation
from the world alone makes the monk". Saint Benedict chose another term to
characterize his disciple; he said his disciple was one who seeks God.
These two ideas are complementary and they give unity to monastic life. If
the monk flees from the world, it is because he has seen its vanity; it is
also because the attraction of God is, for him, greater than any other
attraction in the world. His whole occupation becomes that of Mary of
Bethany; he listens to the Lord, he tells Him all that he desires. Having
left the world, he seeks to leave himself in order that he may enter into
the joy and familiar company of his Master.
His life has only one purpose: to find God. Monasticism was not founded for
any work of any temporal order whatsoever. We must not be deceived by what
Benedictines have actually done--cultivation of the soil of Europe,
preservation of the monuments of the past, preaching the Gospel to pagans,
creation of masterpieces, scholarly works or historical studies, etc. By
vocation the monk is not a farmer, nor a savant, nor an apostle. If it
comes about that he does the work of these men, this work remains purely
accidental as far as his vocation is concerned and can always be traced
back to some contingent, if not fortuitous, circumstance. He must take care
that this work is always subordinate to what is his true work, which we may
call "the work of God", taking this expression in its broadest and most
comprehensive sense. As soon as his true work is in any way endangered or
compromised, his work in the world must be mercilessly sacrificed.
Moreover, the domain in which he is able to do this temporal work is
necessarily restricted because the search for God, as the monk understands
it, requires a more or less complete isolation from the world.
A life separated from the world and its agitation is a life of leisure,
silence, peace. Long ago Saint Anthony described the monastic vocation by
the expression "propositum quietis;" "propositum" means a purpose, a plan,
an ideal of a calm and tranquil life. Saint Benedict wishes peace to
reign in his monastery. No one has the right to disturb this peace, neither
guests (chapter 53), nor visiting monks (chapter 61), nor the cellarer
(chapter 31), nor the prior (chapter 65), nor the abbot (chapters 63 and
64). Monastic spiritual traditions on this point are many. Is it
necessary to add that peace like this is legitimate only if it is the
climate of an intensely active mind? True leisure in the cloister is the
opposite of idleness. It is "purposeful leisure", "negotiosum otium."
How complete should be this separation from the world? Should it be a total
isolation from men? Should it be an absolute solitude? Does the monk's
vocation necessarily take him to the desert? Saint Benedict and his
disciples did not think so. They saw that the eremitical vocation was a
special "charisma" albeit a perfectly legitimate one and one that was quite
in line with their spiritual drives. But the normal place for the monk's
sanctification is in the community. They believed that the community was
singularly helpful in the reformation of character and in the acquisition
of virtues. When Saint Benedict speaks of "good zeal" he has in mind only
virtues that can be exercised within the community, namely: mutual respect,
patience, deference to the desires of others, self-forgetfulness, fraternal
love, a humble and sincere affection for the abbot; and he concludes with
the wish that Christ will lead us all together to life eternal (chapter
The Benedictine community is a family because the abbot is a father and the
monks are brothers. Usually the abbot remains in once until his death and
it is until death that the monks promise to remain in the monastery of
their profession. This stability gives the monastic community solidarity,
security and peace, it is visible in the monastery as a whole and it is
reflected on every face. Perseverance in work, respect for tradition, unity
of minds, love of the common good, all these are the natural fruits of
Asceticism is the foundation of a life completely given to God. In the
choice of corporal austerities, monasticism has held by preference to these
which have come down from the primitive tradition: fasting, abstinence,
watching. Restriction in food and rest seemed to the first monks the means
that were the most obvious and the best fitted to give the body an
undemanding suppleness which is the condition of its submission to the
To gain self-mastery, silence is observed. Silence imposes a barrier that
puts a stop to the sallies of a particularly refractory faculty.
We have seen that Saint Benedict has given a note of moderation to this
asceticism, a very characteristic note of "discretion"
and of humanity. To him all these practices are secondary and his attention
is focused on what is primary, that is, on more interior renunciations.
Nevertheless he has no time for any subtleties. His formulae are few and
simple: Deny self to follow Christ. Be a stranger to what the world does.
Hate self-will (chapter 4). Give up self-will. Those to whom Christ is
dearer than all else choose the narrow path. Because they no longer live to
please themselves, because they submit their plans to the judgment and the
command of another, because they live a stable, community life they wish to
be governed by an abbot (chapter 5). They do not dispose freely either of
their body or of their will (chapter 33). To read the seventh chapter of
the Rule is to see that the monk's whole asceticism is summed up in an
effort of abasement: his ascent to God is described paradoxically in terms
of a descent, humility expressing itself in concrete forms which are at the
same time steps leading up to love and down to the stripping of self.
Saint Benedict's insistence on "negative" virtues is also found in most
other early monastic writers. It would seem that they are agreed that union
with God flowers best on the ruins of self-love. They mistrust virtue or
prayer that is not founded on the most radical abnegation.
"Spiritual exercises" are not unknown to them. But here, again, simplicity
First, let us denounce the now classic formula: Pray and work. "Ora et
labora." This formula omits one member--and not the least necessary one--of
the traditional trilogy: prayer, reading, work.
This is not the place to discuss the final term of the trilogy. Working
with one's hands--for it is to this kind of work that the word applies--has
always been the subject of vehement controversy among monks, especially
since study began to be considered an activity apart from the "spiritual
exercises" of prayer and reading. This is incorrect. Cassian wrote that the
Egyptian cenobites were "convinced that theirs would be a greater purity of
heart and a contemplation all the more sublime if they gave proof of
greater zeal and devotion for work." Saint Benedict thought no
differently. Obviously the object of work was in his eyes above all moral,
it could not be made to serve any temporal interest whatsoever. If the monk
cannot be dispensed from such work it is doubtlessly because of the needs
of earthly existence, it is also and especially because work is an integral
part of the poor and humble life he has chosen and because it helps to
subdue the passions and keep a good psychic balance.
Monastic prayer is first of all communal. It is the work of God, the "opus
Dei par excellence." Saint Benedict wishes that nothing be considered more
important (chapter 43) and he devotes ten chapters of his Rule to its
regulation. But it would seem that the capital and sometimes exclusive
importance accorded the liturgy by the black monks is mostly due to the
influence of communities of canons at the time of Charlemagne (cf. supra,
Before the days of Dom Gueranger and Dom Delatte, the monks did not stress
the importance of worship in their life. However that may be, in giving
this emphasis they were conforming themselves instinctively to the spirit
of the Church. There can be no doubt that it is through the liturgy that
they enter into the intimate life of the Church, and make their own its
thoughts, its sentiments, its interests. It is the liturgy that best
orientates the whole life to God, keeping the soul eager to procure His
glory and dependent on Him for grace.
It must always be observed that early monastic spirituality did not place
official prayer and private prayer in two separate compartments. There was
a real concern in those days about the continuity of prayer. Liturgical
assemblies, while they correspond to an obligation more or less distinctly
realized, obliged less fervent souls to introduce into their lives at least
something of this ideal. Private prayer filled up the intervals of the day:
it accompanied work, punctuated the time devoted to reading with swift
flights (elans) of the soul to God, and was sometimes practiced for its own
sake in the desert oratory or in the solitude of the cell. In the latter
case we have "pure prayer", without words or any other activity. Saint
Benedict allows several moments for this kind of prayer at the end of each
Hour of the divine office (chapter 20) and he leaves each one free to
continue this prayer in private, if grace so inspires (chapter 52).
Reading is in itself completely directed to prayer. Saint Benedict calls it
"lectio divina." The adjective is significant. The monk's first book is the
Bible. In it he finds the answer to his prayer. To read the Bible requires,
assuredly, some effort of reflection and assimilation but above all it
opens to the monk the thought of God, so it is more important to read it
with a receptive mind rather than with a mind overly eager to grind out the
more or less impure flour of one's own thoughts. The assiduous reading of
the Bible little by little leads the monk to prefer divine teaching to any
human thought, however elevated it may be. In it he discovers a security, a
strength, a depth that he will never find in the writings of the
philosophers. The monk's "meditation" consists in reading the Bible, with
occasional interludes of prayer.
Should a distinction be made between "lectio divina" and intellectual work?
Monks who have seriously examined their vocation have always felt impelled
to deny themselves the right to become interested in the profane sciences
or what they used to call the liberal arts. This explains their somewhat
pronounced opposition to humanistic culture and this is quite in line with
their eschatological spirit. Utterly different is their attitude to the
knowledge of God and all that helps towards its acquisition. Provided that
theology is always based on faith, concerned rather with being instructed
with divine doctrine than in spreading out one's own deductions, full of
loving affection for Scripture and other sources of revelation--then there
is no reason to isolate it from what is properly called spiritual life.
This is not a matter of feeling, it must be nourished with doctrine and
founded on truth. The study of religious subjects, even the study of the
Bible, in our day differs in pace and method from that of Saint Benedict's
day. Does this matter, if the spirit of faith is protected and the final
end remains unchanged? Reading will always be "lectio divina" if it seeks
God's thought and tends only to Him.
We must not expect to find in monastic spirituality an exact analysis of
the stages of prayer and the progress of the soul. When Benedictine authors
describe mystic union they prefer to use figures which are almost always
taken from the Bible. Their delicate allusions evoke the reality and arouse
longings, but they do not come to grips with its essence. The idea they
most often give of contemplation, like their vision of all things, has a.
sharply defined eschatological character. Contemplation is, to them, a
desire for the perfect "theory", for the divine vision in its
manifestations and in its perfection. This desire is inspired by love. To
this desire love gives a first satisfaction, a foretaste of heaven, an
awareness of a union that will one day be complete. Ambrose Aupert (d. 783)
wrote: "It is by love that you are possessed". Long before Saint Benedict
saw in filial love, freed from all servile fear, the summit of perfection
Tears are the sign and the result of the divine visit: Tears of regret
because so good a God has been offended; tears of sweet tenderness because
of the contact with His love. The prayer of the repentant sinner and the
prayer of the saint tasting the waters of eternal love--both are marked
with those tears which heaven alone will wipe away.
"Yes, Wisdom said, My servants have entered the paths I have traced for
them. They have abandoned the wicked, lying world that will not bear My
work, nor acknowledge the power of My cross. Like a sign, I have set them
among the nations, so that their silent presence will proclaim to men the
rights of My Father and the nothingness of this world. They keep vigil,
awaiting My return, at times listening eagerly to My word in silence, at
times singing the canticles of their pilgrimage.
They seem unmindful of other men, their brothers, yet in their hearts they
enfold them in the embrace of an ardent love because their hearts are
filled with God.
I am in their midst, an invisible fountain of life, because they are
gathered together in My Name.
My servants, said Wisdom, are sons of the resurrection: their lives which
are the beginning of heaven on earth flower on the cross."
1. A praiseworthy account is given in "Histoire de l'Ordre de S. Benoit,"
D. SCHMITZ, Maredsous, 1942-1949, II, IV, pp. 309-393; VI, II, pp. 149-326.
2. The only date of his life that is definitely certain is the year 546,
when he had an interview with Sabinus, bishop of Canossa. It would seem
that Benedict died shortly after this.
3. "Benedictine Monasticism," p. 314.
4. Saint GREGORY, "Dialogues," III 98.
5. Cassian was a Roumanian monk who made a tour of the monastic colonies in
Egypt and who set down his findings in writing for the benefit of the
monasteries he had founded in Provence, (d. about 435).
6. CASSIAN, "Institutions," v, 27.
7. The greatest figure, if not the father of Egyptian cenobitic life. He
died in 348.
8. CASSIAN, op. cit., IV, 8.
9. "Sinn und Geist der Benediktinerretgel," Einsiedeln, 1944, p. 22.
10. CF. "Consultationes Zacchaei et Apollonii," Book III, chapter III,
Morin ed., pp. 101-102; Saint AMBROSE, "Epist." 63, section 66 (PL., 16,
1207); Saint AUGUSTINE, "De Moribus Eccl. Cath.," chapter 33 (PL., 32,
11. "Aux origines du breviaire," Maison-Dieu, 27, pp. 132-133. Cf. p. 121.
12. "Deux importantes publications monastiques", "Questions sur l'Eglise et
sur son unite" (Irenikon) Chevetogne, 1943, pp. 50-51. Cf. HENRY, "Moines
et chanoines, Vie Spirituelle," 80; pp. 53-55, 58-62.
13. "Pierre le Venerable," Saint-Waindrille, 1946.
14. This is the title suggested by D. WILMART, "Revue benedictine," 1926,
15. Cf. D. J. LECLERCQ and J. P. BONNES, "Un maitre de la vie spirituelle
au XI siecle, Jean de Fecamp," Paris, 1946.
16. Cf. D. J. LECLERCQ, "La spiritualite de Pierre de Celle," Paris 1946.
17. "Epist." VI, 5 (PL., 144, 380).
18. "Revue benedictine," 1934, pp. 296-305.
19. Cf. DOM BERLIERE, "Documents inedits pour servir a l'histoire
ecclesiastique de la Belgique," Maredsous, 1894, I, pp. 100-101.
20. "Revue benedictine," 1938, p.99.
21. "De decem Aegypti plagis," chapter 13, (PL., 145, 694).
22. "Les origines cisterciennes," Revue Mabillon, 1932-1933. I cite this
work merely for the excellent way in which the true meaning of the reform
is presented. On other points it is not above criticism. Cf. LENSSEN, "Le
fondateur de Citeaux, S. Robert." Collectanea Ord. Cist. Ref. IV, 1937, p.
23. GILSON, "The Mystical thought of St. Bernard," Paris, 1934, pp. 79-80.
24. This thought comes from J. LECLERCQ, "Medievisme et unionisme",
"Irenikon," 1946, p. 13.
25. On this phenomenon, cf. D. FR. VANDENBROUCKE, "Le divorce entre
theologie et mystique. Ses origines. Nouvelle Revue Theol.," 1950, pp. 372-
389. The basic theological thesis of the spiritual current known as
"Devotio moderna" is that contemplation is purely a matter of love and does
not need the support of a distinct thought.
26. Cf. D. SCHMITZ, "Histoire de l'Ordre de S. Benoit," III, I, chapter I.
27. Op. cit., pp. 5-6.
28. "Traite des Etudes monastiques," Paris, 1691, p. 139.
29. BREMOND, "Histoire litteraire du sentiment religieux en France," II,
Paris, 1916, pp. 421-422.
30. "Pratique de la Regle de Saint Benoit," Paris, 1700 (5th edition).
31. "Avis et reflexions sur les devoirs de l'etat religieux," Paris, 1737.
32. Op. cit., VI, 1926, pp. 97-98.
33. "La vie monastique. Ses principes essentiels," Maredsous, N.-d.
34. "Commentaire sur al regle de Saint Benoit," Paris, 1913.
35. "Le Christ, ideal du moine," Maredsous, 1922.
36. "Le monachisme benedictin," Paris, 1924.
37. Sinn und Geist der Benediktinerregel," Einsiedeln, 1944; Saint Benoit,
38. "L'ascese chretienne," Chevetogne, 1948.
39. "Le moine dans l'Eglise du Christ," Louvain, 1947.
40. "Le sens de la vie monastique," Paris-Turnhout, 1951.
41. "Die Regel St. Benedikts," Beuron, 1952.
42. Need I explain that when I attribute a feeling or a thought to "a
monk," I have in mind an ideal type and not a concrete and always faulty
fulfillment of this type.
43. Cf. "I Cor.," 7, 31; "II Pet.," 3, 1-13.
44. "Apologeticum de contemptu saeculi," chapter 27, (PL., 145, 280).
45. "Verba seniorum," I, II, 1, (PL., 73, 858).
46. Cf. D. J. LECLERCQ, "La spiritualite de Pierre de Celle," VI, "Otium
47. "Institutions," II, 12.
48. "In Apocalypsin," Max. Bibl. Patrum, Lyons, 1677, XIII, p. 656.
iuaio [url=http://www.im-mulberrybags.co.uk]mulberry bags[/url] osqewj http://www.im-mulberrybags.co.uk nloki [url=http://www.im-mulberryoutlet.co.uk]mulberry outlet[/url] dfihsj http://www.im-mulberryoutlet.co.uk kgmua [url=http://www.pay-mulberrybags.co.uk]mulberry outlet[/url] klvdku http://www.pay-mulberrybags.co.uk vpah [url=http://www.online-mulberry.co.uk]mulberry handbags[/url] mcxekk http://www.online-mulberry.co.uk rkwxg [url=http://www.goodcelinehandbags.com]mulberry handbags[/url] azfdaj http://www.goodcelinehandbags.com husce [url=http://www.onlinecelinebags.com]mulberry bags[/url] suxjlg http://www.onlinecelinebags.com agfg
qpurt [url=http://www.purchasingcheapbeatsbydre.com]beats by dre[/url] gnjug http://www.purchasingcheapbeatsbydre.com qnezf [url=http://www.drdrebeatsxiao.com]dr dre beats[/url] iqkbi http://www.drdrebeatsxiao.com bbwbe [url=http://www.goonebeatsbydre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] gvrjg http://www.goonebeatsbydre.com lfqhq [url=http://www.vip-beatsbydresale.com]dr dre beats[/url] jgywq http://www.vip-beatsbydresale.com ietc [url=http://www.drdrebeatsnamew.com]beats by dre[/url] hdatm http://www.drdrebeatsnamew.com ktjh [url=http://www.beatsbydrenameq.com]dr dre beats[/url] tyrqd http://www.beatsbydrenameq.com sxop
ihiadq http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com ocmlkg http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com hsfihm http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com gapsee http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com hxlzpc http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com yqatmw [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] ztpqu [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] rlvwd [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc[/url] ahrmh [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]beats by dre[/url] nqoqgc [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] tpnt
gpxlzw http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com euzdvk http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com ghbomx http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com bkxhgp http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com iwsbxg http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com llcmem [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] wynes [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] wvygu [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc[/url] laacu [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]beats by dre[/url] uachye [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] dvyk
nvtemw http://abc-louisvuittonoutlet.com gtrdqj http://www.canadagoosehut.com esvlkl http://www.mymontblancforcheap.com muksnp http://beatsbydrecheapp.com ratoyv http://alouisvuittonoutlet-au.com sjyesr [url=http://abc-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] tglwh [url=http://www.canadagoosehut.com]canada goose[/url] ynuzb [url=http://www.mymontblancforcheap.com]mont blanc[/url] fjobp [url=http://beatsbydrecheapp.com]beats by dre[/url] moqivt [url=http://alouisvuittonoutlet-au.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] okqg
osxxcy http://www.mocanadagoosejackets.com iyjrfr http://icheapbeatsbyddre.com smrobt http://www.mocanadagooseoutlet.com eaftpl http://socheapbeatsbydree.com qwggib [url=http://www.mocanadagoosejackets.com]canada goose[/url] hyxhl [url=http://icheapbeatsbyddre.com]dr dre beats[/url] znlshk [url=http://www.mocanadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] syhrt [url=http://socheapbeatsbydree.com]beats by dre[/url] kxtukr [url=http://palouisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] vnfdrz [url=http://pa-louisvuittoncheap.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] tjjy
szwegw http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com rbwjxr http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com yduupm http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com clhbup http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com kxqluo http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com xwtrjk [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] lxlwn [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] fkamt [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc[/url] ptrbt [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] lgasfv [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] uqgq
hwysfx http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com spvpzi http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com ehscwm http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com jlsyvq http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com mrfzhm http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com ewanjk [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] bpecx [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] qulyx [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]cheap mont blanc[/url] spzmj [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] wmlieh [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] hrxs
lrquch http://abc-louisvuittonoutlet.com fhxusp http://www.canadagoosehut.com oikvbu http://www.mymontblancforcheap.com avfwvr http://beatsbydrecheapp.com oaydqp http://alouisvuittonoutlet-au.com mkhmph [url=http://abc-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton handbags[/url] naikd [url=http://www.canadagoosehut.com]canada goose outlet[/url] ssvsr [url=http://www.mymontblancforcheap.com]mont blanc[/url] cnxof [url=http://beatsbydrecheapp.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] hfzuzj [url=http://alouisvuittonoutlet-au.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] cayh
gprjxf http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com etkqgk http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com ylywuu http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com fcdhit http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com dbjimb http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com qejktc [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton handbags[/url] insev [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] mevxx [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc pens[/url] jzpzo [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] ebxias [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] lmpz
pdgerx http://pa-louisvuittoncheap.com aiqjjb http://www.mccanadagooseoutlet.com enyaxu http://www.sale-cheapmontblanc.com vgdxoe http://cheaperbeatssbydre.com hchgwn http://palouisvuittonoutlet.com rvvojc [url=http://pa-louisvuittoncheap.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] wymwj [url=http://www.mccanadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] mzqrj [url=http://www.sale-cheapmontblanc.com]cheap mont blanc[/url] scmvq [url=http://cheaperbeatssbydre.com]beats by dre[/url] gkuhiy [url=http://palouisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] xnoh
hercaw http://www.mocanadagoosejackets.com wqlkrw http://icheapbeatsbyddre.com rqhtua http://www.mocanadagooseoutlet.com gfvrcu http://socheapbeatsbydree.com lqygrf [url=http://www.mocanadagoosejackets.com]canada goose outlet[/url] yxjiy [url=http://icheapbeatsbyddre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] fzrnln [url=http://www.mocanadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] ccbwx [url=http://socheapbeatsbydree.com]beats by dre[/url] pcooue [url=http://palouisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] buizqm [url=http://pa-louisvuittoncheap.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] ikkq
opmuim http://pa-louisvuittoncheap.com mbofpr http://www.mccanadagooseoutlet.com gbuonn http://www.sale-cheapmontblanc.com kwumrl http://cheaperbeatssbydre.com dnlgom http://palouisvuittonoutlet.com fkarqs [url=http://pa-louisvuittoncheap.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] xooae [url=http://www.mccanadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] yeesv [url=http://www.sale-cheapmontblanc.com]mont blanc[/url] pscjw [url=http://cheaperbeatssbydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] pybqrl [url=http://palouisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] hgic
znugoh http://louisvuittonooutlet-shop.com wkoddz http://beatsbydree-sales.com tpacrh http://newlouisvuitton.webs.com tgwiqi http://nikeairmaxb.webs.com zfhbxe http://beatsbydree-4u.com jctggm [url=http://louisvuittonooutlet-shop.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] qppev [url=http://newlouisvuitton.webs.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] updpei [url=http://beatsbydree-online.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] cfmlj [url=http://nikeairmaxb.webs.com]nike air max[/url] xarguy [url=http://beatsbydree-4u.com]beats by dre[/url] rype
bduaqt http://louisvuittonooutlet-sales.com pucdsm http://beatsbydree-shop.com wnchyb http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html pgewmq http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html jeipkk http://louisvuittonooutlet-mm.com qzplhp [url=http://louisvuittonooutlet-sales.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] kpfwp [url=http://beatsbydree-shop.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] zrxlt [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton handbags[/url] bnppy [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] viljtf [url=http://louisvuittonooutlet-mm.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] dtpf
ehruov http://louisvuittonooutlet-sales.com hmxtgu http://beatsbydree-shop.com oksajp http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html zlejkp http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html tqqjld http://louisvuittonooutlet-mm.com ofssee [url=http://louisvuittonooutlet-sales.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] cyupz [url=http://beatsbydree-shop.com]dr dre beats[/url] bwxit [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton handbags[/url] riyin [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]nike air max[/url] cregxm [url=http://louisvuittonooutlet-mm.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] plld
enbbcy http://louisvuittonooutlet-online.com ziqhtj http://beatsbydree-online.com eafeib http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html plmqnv http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html ixlypy http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html trheie [url=http://louisvuittonooutlet-online.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] mwnbx [url=http://beatsbydree-online.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] zrowg [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlaet.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] ychlx [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] kifbxp [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bag[/url] bihc
ydltsy http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html cywmpm http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html lrxgwa http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html slrjyj http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html vngwvn http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html komyiq [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton handbags[/url] korjj [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]nike air max[/url] mkjki [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] yawup [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] kciuwg [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bag[/url] hcog
phsyvm http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html xcorlt http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html pekoit http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html gltqzb http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html feysah http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html tfenxx [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] ondqk [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton handbags[/url] yoihn [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] wtbxc [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] sqoeui [url=http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] nxze
xcrjzb http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html zwwuxw http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html qorxll http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html fcpccx http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html sfwqcg http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html qmxajb [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bag[/url] cyymu [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]air max shoes[/url] qbsaw [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] soehy [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]air max[/url] kfaczo [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] ltmg
bkwaui http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html jlwhxg http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html anxfoe http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html gnqfpv http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html hzluzp http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html teaeet [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bags[/url] xcqia [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]air max shoes[/url] swzeb [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] eiask [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]nike air max[/url] rypgqc [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]air max[/url] vkwv
uniigq http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html qwvvdk http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html xzpxsh http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html svojpj http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html yocckc http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html wnveub [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] hcqfc [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]cheap air max[/url] ernun [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] ijkhi [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]air max[/url] woniul [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bags[/url] iqtp
suzdrs http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html vmexgb http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html bglacz http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html iihuvi http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html jxfcjf http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html fkjiev [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton handbags[/url] xadxq [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]cheap air max[/url] stdky [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] cbwwt [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] cfmniw [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bag[/url] rvat
xndqxv http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html rtqiiy http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html xukfwk http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html xsxclg http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html rsmmlv http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html jzjjmx [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] ujqdn [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] pmufw [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton bags[/url] subdi [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]air max[/url] okjnfo [url=http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] irku
aloyrn http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html mkbvxh http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html zsjspo http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html gmhfbu http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html eyzjqg http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html vmttrl [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] ndmcs [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]cheap air max[/url] mlatg [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] zudjw [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]air max[/url] spzjmk [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bags[/url] xxzr
mtrshl http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html wsmqww http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html kyxxns http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html vfnxjf http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html fwtezi http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html zkuiul [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine handbags[/url] rarnb [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]nike air max[/url] ykdas [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] xywlj [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]air max[/url] mlispj [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] ipui
eznjxo http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html exahzb http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html rvknzl http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html akjeiq http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html ffhtwz http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html mbvqkq [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] pvvst [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] scuzq [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton bags[/url] pbdcq [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]air max[/url] saespz [url=http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]nike air max[/url] dfsq
qpvplj http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html kunkuv http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html dswrey http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html qvvjdr http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html asuicq http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html auheav [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton bags[/url] cssyo [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton bags[/url] kyiug [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] hfmaw [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]nike air max[/url] cqhmyt [url=http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]nike air max[/url] hydd
cqigci http://www.capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html szawqa http://chancemccann.com/nikeairmaxb.html yulziy http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html xyjtht http://chancemccann.com/nikeairmaxb.html xftoeb http://www.oceancityseafood.com/cheapnikeshoesb.html nwuglq [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]nike air max[/url] wfdmv [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] keryhd [url=http://chancemccann.com/nikeairmaxb.html]air max shoes[/url] vgjbc [url=http://chancemccann.com/nikeairmaxb.html]air max[/url] nmkexv [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/cheapnikeshoesb.html]air max shoes[/url] hvzj
vkkgmr http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html iiyejj http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html oalhqz http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html gzpeim http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html lmnrre http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html bmkzrx [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton handbags[/url] lzjww [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/nikeairmax.html]nike air max[/url] belhp [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] sseaz [url=http://maryhelverson.com/cheapnikeshoesc.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] rfeuoc [url=http://www.chancemccann.com/celinebag.html]celine bag[/url] prfz
snetsy http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html cmswby http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html funeht http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html mvbgmt http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html cldwao http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html ksyrnt [url=http://www.capemaycitypolice.com/louisVuittonHandbags.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] qzlih [url=http://www.capeMayLinen.com/louisVuittonOutlet.html]louis vuitton bags[/url] hkwpu [url=http://www.oceancityseafood.com/louisVuittonOutletb.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] ngbzg [url=http://maryhelverson.com/nikeairmaxcheap.html]air max[/url] ritkjl [url=http://capeMayLinen.com/cheapnikeshoes.html]cheap nike shoes[/url] wpaw
Post a Comment